Trucking Accidents and Negligent Entrustment

Attorney Blog


Auto accidents involving semis and other large trucks are dangerous, due to the size of the vehicles involved. They often result in more serious injuries and a higher mortality rate, especially if a smaller vehicle is involved. Generally, only the driver is held liable in an auto accident. But in some cases, if the driver is not the owner of the truck, the doctrine of negligent entrustment applies, and the owner can be held legally responsible. If you have been injured in a trucking accident, an attorney can help you navigate the complex legal issues involved in recovering compensation for your injuries.

Negligent Entrustment

If the owner of a truck allows someone else to drive his or her vehicle, the owner must take reasonable care to make sure that the driver is competent and safe. In Illinois, the doctrine of negligent entrustment allows the owners of a truck, often a trucking company, to be held liable if they allowed an unsafe driver to use their vehicle. To prove negligent entrustment, an accident victim must demonstrate that:

  • The owner owned the truck;
  • The owner knew or should have known that driver could not operate the truck safely, but let the driver drive anyway; and
  • That entrustment was the proximate cause of the victim’s injuries.

Negligent entrustment is useful to trucking accident victims because individual drivers often do not have the funds or insurance coverage necessary to compensate the victims for all their losses. Trucking companies, on the other hand, generally have more resources.


For an owner of a truck to be liable under negligent entrustment, he or she must either have exclusive ownership of the vehicle or a superior right to control it. If the driver who caused the accident is a co-owner, then no entrustment occurred, and the other owner cannot be held liable under negligent entrustment.

Knowledge and Permission

The owner’s knowledge is key to the doctrine of negligent entrustment. To be responsible for a victim’s injuries, the owner must have had actual or constructive knowledge of the driver’s inability to drive safely. An owner has actual knowledge, for example, if the owner knew that the driver was intoxicated, yet let the driver operate the vehicle regardless.

An owner has constructive knowledge of a driver’s incapacity if he or she should have known that the driver was not capable. For example, this could occur if an owner failed to monitor a driver’s performance or was not reasonably diligent in ensuring that the driver had a license and a relatively clean driving record. This makes sure that truck owners cannot avoid responsibility for negligent entrustment by purposely remaining ignorant of a driver’s performance and ability.

A truck owner may give permission to a driver to use a truck either expressly or impliedly. An owner’s permission is implied if the owner and driver have a relationship or course of conduct that includes such permission.

Proximate Cause

The proximate cause requirement means that it must be foreseeable that harm would result if the driver were allowed to operate the truck. If, for example, an owner knew that a driver was unlicensed, it would be foreseeable that the driver would crash the truck and injure someone, and proximate cause would exist.

Comparative Negligence

Just because a truck owner was negligent and can be held legally responsible for a victim’s injuries does not mean that the driver is not also responsible. In Illinois, the driver and the owner can share responsibility for the injury and resultant damages. The court will determine the percentage of each party’s responsibility, and damages will be allocated accordingly.

If you have been injured in an auto accident involving a truck or other commercial vehicle, please contact a trucking accidents attorney at Woodruff Johnson & Evans Law Offices for a free initial consultation at our offices in Aurora, Chicago, or Champaign.


Mr. Russell Haugen is the best injury attorney in the Chicago area!

In my opinion, Mr. Russell Haugen is the best personal injury attorney in the Chicago area. He is very professional and very hard working person for his clients. His knowledge allowed me to have a good ending for my case. He was awesome to work with. The process took several months but the settled was […]

Barbara I.

Great People to Work With!

They are on top of everything. Great people to work with! Thank you so much for everything you done for me.

Deanna S.

Lee got my Work Compensation checks coming in!

I hired this firm when I got hurt at work. I’m glad I did because my company wasn’t sending any checks. Leandro got my checks coming after talking to workers compensation. The work comp company wasn’t easy to deal with. I’m glad I could relax and let Leandro and Kristal go after them. It took […]

Brian M

Excellent Service.

Very good and professional service I received from Dexter.

Jaime G.

Thanks Jay Johnson!

Very responsive. Always called back and always had an answer to my questions and concerns. Jay handled everything and I just sat back and waited for results. I’ve seen him fight for friends who went through the same situation I did and they all have nothing but good things to say about him. Hopefully I […]

Elizabeth V

Best in town.

They will handle your case. Best in town. They beat everyone.

Striker M

Very Persistent and Very Honest!

After Mr. Evans took over my case, it didn’t take long to get results. I recommend Mr. Evans if you want to get results quick he very persistent and very honest with his clients.

Timothy A

He settled my case for more than I had expected.

Mr. Haugen is always so very kind and very involved with his client. He’s very attentive when it comes to his client relationship. Any questions I had for him were always answered in a very timely fashion, and explained very well. He settled my case for more than I had expected. Great Attorney! Highly Recommended!

Molly P

Thank you so much for great service and representation!

Attorney Russ Haugen was truly amazing. He kept in touch with me every time there was new information or changes with my case. The company he represents were very professional every time I called and responded back within a reasonable amount of time. I would recommend not only Russ Haugen to represent you, but the […]

Alexis W

Russ fought for me and I received more than double from the 1st settlement offer.

In July of 2018 I injured my back on the job. I was advised by someone to find a lawyer. I was given Woodruff Johnson & Evans Law Offices telephone number. I called and had a consultation with Russell Haugen. I knew nothing as far as what to do or expect. He was very informative […]

Sheryl D
View All Testimonials

Get Your Free Consultation