Man Crushed at Caterpillar Allowed the Right to Inspect

Attorney Blog

When a man is crushed by a 36 ton machine at work we should all be concerned. Concerned for the man who lost his life and his family and concerned for anyone else who might find themselves exposed to the same risk in the future. Therefore, it was no surprise that the United Steel, Paper and Forestry, Rubber, Manufacturing, Energy, Allied Industrial and Service Workers International Union wanted to inspect the accident scene to find out answers for Jeffrey Smith’s family and to protect his coworkers. When the union attempted to send their safety expert as part of their emergency response team, Mr. Smith’s employer, Caterpillar, refused to allow the expert on its property.  Caterpillar insisted its property rights trumped the right of the union to conduct an inspection and that the inspection was unnecessary.

The National Labor Relations Board agreed with the union and determined that Caterpillar had engaged in an unfair labor practice by violating the rights of its employees and ordered the company to allow the union’s expert onto the premises for investigation. Caterpillar appealed this to the U.S. Court of Appeals and the U.S. Court of Appeals recently found that “the union’s duty to attend to the safety of the employees whom it represents entitles it to insist on performing its own investigation of safety issues, rather than relying entirely on the data given it by the company.”

When someone dies in the workplace it is important not to rely merely on the company’s investigation as to the circumstances surrounding that death. In this instance the deceased benefited by the role of a strong union and their insistence that they be allowed an investigation by their own expert. Likewise, affiliating with a law firm that handles workplace death cases will ensure that the right experts do the right investigations as soon as possible after an accident occurs.  As the court of appeals said in support of the investigation “the cost on the company would be negligible, and the benefit to the union would not be limited…might well lead to changes in the weld shop that reduce the likelihood of a future accident.”

Don’t rely on the experts hired by the people that may have caused your accident. Hire your own expert. Hire your own lawyer. Learn the truth.



He re-opened my case and got me a total knee replacement.

I was one of those guys that thought WC insurance would take care of me without legal representation. Then one day in the middle of being treated they closed my case without warning. When I questioned the WC insurance agent I caught her in a blatant lie and contacted Russell Haugen at my wife’s recommendation. […]

Jeff R.

I would recommend Jay to any one

Mr. Jay Johnson handle my case very fast. I would recommend him to any one. He kept in contact with me and kept me updated with every thing that was going on. Thank you again Woodruff Johnson and Evans for your help.

D. Fitts

Highly Recommended

Steve Sandler did an awesome job for me. His dogged determination resulted in an even better outcome than I expected. Plus, he’s super nice, accessible, and a good communicator. Highly recommended.

M. Charles

Russell Haugen went above and beyond!

After being in a terrible car accident my attorney, Russell Haugen went above and beyond to getting me my compensation. I’m really satisfied with his work and it was all done in a reasonable amount of time. He also did an amazing job in explaining in detail his plans and cleared any questions I had […]


I will not hesitate to recommend your services to others.

Casey, It was a genuine pleasure to have your firm work on my case. Your professionalism in this matter was great. You listened to my concerns and helped me move forward from a previous firm that was not representing my best interest. I will not hesitate to recommend your services to others.


Sending a big thank you!

Steve, Sending a big thank you! After all that time and hassle, you were finally able to get justice for me. I can’t even tell me how good that makes me feel, nor can I adequately express my appreciation. Way to go, Steve!


I was very satisfied with the results!

I was referred to Woodruff Johnson & Evans by a friend who had used them in the past. Everyone I had contact with was so kind and polite. My lawyer, Jay Johnson, explained the process to me so that I understood what was happening with my case. He was very patient, keeping me informed and […]


I was very happy with the outcome of my case!

A friend referred me to Woodruff Johnson & Evans. Attorney Jay Johnson explained the process so that I understood what was going on with my case. He was responsive to my situation and kept me informed as my case progressed. Jay did great. He knows what he is doing. I was very happy with the […]


I will definitely recommend them!

I was injured in an auto accident and Dexter Evans handled my case. He was awesome. I will definitely recommend them to friends and family.


They always keep in touch & are quick to respond.

I want to thank attorney Jon Walker for all his work on my worker’s comp case. He explains everything in detail to you so you understand. Always kept in touch, you didn’t have to wait for long to get a response back. I highly recommend attorney Jon Walker.

View All Testimonials

Get Your Free Consultation