What Is the “Burden of Proof” in My Civil Case?

Attorney Blog

undefinedMany people believe that, simply because they are injured as result of another’s negligence, they are entitled to any and all medical treatment they receive for any injury that may develop after the accident. However, simply being involved in an accident does not ensure that you will recover damages against a third person or entity. A plaintiff has to show by a preponderance of the evidence not only that the third party was negligent, but also that this negligence was the proximate cause of their injury. This is what is called the burden of proof.

A plaintiff always has the burden of proving their case at trial. Preponderance of the evidence is a fancy way of saying that a given proposition is more probably true than not. Essentially, you need to show that the crucial issues/elements of your case are in your favor by more than 50%. Contrast this with the burden that a prosecutor has in a criminal trial, beyond a reasonable doubt. To be sure, this is a much higher burden to meet and is not required for civil trials.  What is the reason for a different standard? The stakes are much higher in a criminal case where someone’s freedom is at stake. However, it is important that jurors understand the difference in a civil case so that they are not holding plaintiffs to the much higher standard which, quite frankly, would be difficult to overcome in a civil case where people often have preexisting conditions or prior injuries to the same body part.

In Illinois, a plaintiff must only show that the accident was a contributing factor in the resulting injury. Thus, if the accident was at least a 1% cause of the injury, it is sufficient to establish proximate cause.  How does this work when I said earlier that the burden is more than 50%? Well, you need to show that it is more probably true than not that the accident was at least a contributing factor in causing the injury. If you meet that burden, you win. This is of utmost importance when you have an injury to a body part for which you had already received treatment in the past or for which you have an underlying degenerative condition.

Simply put, explaining the burden of proof to a jury is not easy, especially the way in which TV shows and movies have skewed the general public’s view. Seasoned trial lawyers understand the way in which the burden of proof must be explained to a jury and to ensure that jurors do not confuse it with the much higher criminal standard.


DJ did a fantastic job on my auto-accident claim!

I highly recommend Mr. Dexter Evans, and the Woodruff law firm. DJ did a fantastic job on my auto-accident claim. I really appreciated all the detailed information provided, and finding medical assistance for me. It was awesome. All my questions were addressed properly and asap. I made my final decision with confidence. Over all the […]

Lilia G.

I’ve had to know a few attorneys in my life and Jon was the best.

Unfortunately, I got badly injured at an athletic job. Run by a company that didn’t care about me. I needed an attorney and Woodruff, Johnson and Evans was recommended to me by a family member. That small gesture ended up being the best legal advice I ever received. Jon Walker defended me and made sure […]

Marko P.

I wouldn’t have gotten the relief from my injury if Jay had not gotten involved.

I was referred to Woodruff, Johnson & Evans by a friend after a work related car accident. The workmen comp adjuster was giving me the run around. I was having terrible back pain but because it was work related my doctors could not provide me the treatment I need. Jay Johnson began investigating my case […]

Randel M

Outstanding job for my mother and me.

Very professional. Was referred to me by my mother. Did an outstanding job for my mother and me. Great service!

Valente G

Russ was the best!

Russ was the best! I got his number from my cousin. Best phone call I ever made! Always there for anything I needed and got all my bills paid and some compensation for me! Highly recommend.

Timothy F

Thank you for a good service!!

Steve Sandler presented himself professionally with good rapport and showed concern for my well being. I will definitely recommend him to others!! Thank you!!

Sherifat O

This man knows what he is doing.

I can’t say enough about Jon Walker. He took my case after being denied. Told me everything I had to do and kept me calm during the wait and got me approved! If you want a professional lawyer who knows how to get you approved call WOODRUFF JOHNSON & EVANS I cannot thank you enough […]

Steve G

Far beyond what I expected!

Russ Haugen helped me far beyond what I expected. He was polite and communicated with me every step of the way. Thank you for everything!

Mikahl S

I really felt like I had an ally!

Jon Walker represented me in a Work Comp case. I really felt like I had an ally and someone who was going to protect me and my rights after I was injured at work. Jon was extremely attentive and available to me when I had questions or needed advice throughout the entire process. Also, Jon […]

Juli T

Recommendation to Blessing

I had a lawyer working on my insurance claim that was extremely unprofessional and after 8 months of getting nowhere, I fired him. Dexter Evans was recommended to me by a family member. He was extremely professional and made the insurance claim very easy for me. He was very informative and always got back to […]

Brooke D
View All Testimonials

Get Your Free Consultation