Withholding Workers’ Compensation Benefits

Attorney Blog

Work injury claim denied

My Employer is Withholding Workers’ Compensation Benefits for No Reason – What Can I Do?

Penalties and Attorney Fees

Throughout my career there have been many times where my client has done everything right in pursuing their workers’ compensation benefits –timely notice of the injury was given, the worker promptly sought medical attention, was compliant with the doctor’s recommended course of treatment, and off-work slips were timely submitted to the employer. And yet the insurance company still refused to pay weekly TTD benefits and/or denied medical treatment! 

What recourse does the injured worker have when benefits are denied without a reasonable explanation?

First and foremost the injured workers’ attorney must file a 19b/8a Petitioner for an Immediate Hearing. In addition to an emergency hearing the Petitioner can also file for penalties against the employer for their unreasonable delay payment of benefits. The Illinois Worker’s Compensation Act provides for the following penalties:   

  • Section19(l) is a late fee and applies whenever the employer fails, neglects or refuses to make payment or unreasonably delays payment without good cause.  Section 19(l) provides a $30 per day penalty for each day that weekly TTD benefits are unreasonably withheld, subject to a $10,000 maximum. 
  • Section 19(k) authorizes a penalty of 50% of the amount payable at the time of an award.
  • Section 16 provides for attorneys’ fees and costs. Both Sections 19(k) and 16 apply are assessed when the employer unreasonably or vexatiously delays payment, for an intentional underpayment of compensation or where proceedings have been instituted by the one liable to pay the compensation, which do not present a real controversy, but are merely frivolous or for delay.

Generally, an employer’s reasonable and good-faith challenge to liability does not warrant penalties.

Thus, penalties are typically not awarded when there are conflicting medical opinions between the Petitioner’s treating physician and the employer’s IME physician, even if it turns out that the IME physician is wrong. However, the Commission has awarded penalties against the Employer for the following conduct—

  • Failure to provide proper notice of termination of TTD.
  • Failure to timely pay a non-disputed award of benefits.
  • Failure to immediately pay a statutory amputation benefits.
  • Deliberate delay in payment of benefits.
  • Deliberate underpayment of benefits.

Fortunately, the Act provides penalties for bad faith conduct of employer/insurance companies.

If your checks are consistently late or withheld unreasonably, you should talk to an experienced workers’ compensation lawyer, who can help you recover penalties which you are entitled to. 

For more information visit our Workers’ Compensation Overview page. 

If you have questions please call or submit a CONTACT FORM today. 


He re-opened my case and got me a total knee replacement.

I was one of those guys that thought WC insurance would take care of me without legal representation. Then one day in the middle of being treated they closed my case without warning. When I questioned the WC insurance agent I caught her in a blatant lie and contacted Russell Haugen at my wife’s recommendation. […]

Jeff R.

I would recommend Jay to any one

Mr. Jay Johnson handle my case very fast. I would recommend him to any one. He kept in contact with me and kept me updated with every thing that was going on. Thank you again Woodruff Johnson and Evans for your help.

D. Fitts

Highly Recommended

Steve Sandler did an awesome job for me. His dogged determination resulted in an even better outcome than I expected. Plus, he’s super nice, accessible, and a good communicator. Highly recommended.

M. Charles

Russell Haugen went above and beyond!

After being in a terrible car accident my attorney, Russell Haugen went above and beyond to getting me my compensation. I’m really satisfied with his work and it was all done in a reasonable amount of time. He also did an amazing job in explaining in detail his plans and cleared any questions I had […]


I will not hesitate to recommend your services to others.

Casey, It was a genuine pleasure to have your firm work on my case. Your professionalism in this matter was great. You listened to my concerns and helped me move forward from a previous firm that was not representing my best interest. I will not hesitate to recommend your services to others.


Sending a big thank you!

Steve, Sending a big thank you! After all that time and hassle, you were finally able to get justice for me. I can’t even tell me how good that makes me feel, nor can I adequately express my appreciation. Way to go, Steve!


I was very satisfied with the results!

I was referred to Woodruff Johnson & Evans by a friend who had used them in the past. Everyone I had contact with was so kind and polite. My lawyer, Jay Johnson, explained the process to me so that I understood what was happening with my case. He was very patient, keeping me informed and […]


I was very happy with the outcome of my case!

A friend referred me to Woodruff Johnson & Evans. Attorney Jay Johnson explained the process so that I understood what was going on with my case. He was responsive to my situation and kept me informed as my case progressed. Jay did great. He knows what he is doing. I was very happy with the […]


I will definitely recommend them!

I was injured in an auto accident and Dexter Evans handled my case. He was awesome. I will definitely recommend them to friends and family.


They always keep in touch & are quick to respond.

I want to thank attorney Jon Walker for all his work on my worker’s comp case. He explains everything in detail to you so you understand. Always kept in touch, you didn’t have to wait for long to get a response back. I highly recommend attorney Jon Walker.

View All Testimonials

Get Your Free Consultation